I first came across Elna Baker’s stories on This American Life and Moth podcasts. Her enthusiasm, when talking about her various adventures, is infectious. She sounds incredibly fun, and her hilarious anecdotes make you want to be her best friend. If you have heard her radio stories, you will already be familiar with about half the content of her book, which consists of essays on various significant moments in her life, loosely tied up together with overarching themes of body image, romantic relationships, and Mormon religion. The latter is especially present, but even if that sort of thing doesn’t normally appeal to you, don’t let it scare you off.
The fact that people do get scared off is actually a major issue for Baker. As a result, she writes about Mormonism so apologetically that you can’t help but respect her for it even if you happen to be
particularly irreligious. Her religion informed many of her decisions while growing up, and continues doing so well into adulthood. It’s a big source of humour in her stories. Ultimately, though the effects of her beliefs are often tackled lightly, you can sense inner turmoil brewing. She doubts her faith more and more toward the end of the book, and clearly comes to think that some of the restrictions and expectations imposed on her are unreasonable. It makes me wonder whether she still considers herself Mormon today.
There are numerous online reviews for The New York Regional Mormon Singles Halloween Dance written by Mormons, many of them disappointed. They mostly seem annoyed at her frankness regarding certain subjects as well as her occasional swearing; essentially, they fear her representing Mormons in a bad light. But really, these reviews emphasize how careful she constantly has to be, in order not to upset anyone in her church or her family, not to mention how admirably she has dealt with keeping a foot in both religious and secular worlds. It sounds like so much work. In my favourite of her stories, she talks about how she tries to say ‘yes’ to anything that comes her way, because she otherwise is obligated to say ‘no’ to lot of other experiences. It’s a system that often works well for her, but as already mentioned, the ‘no’ parts end up far being trickier than she bargained for.
Before I give the wrong impression, I should mention that, despite my fascination with the underlying frustrations in this book, Baker is actually a really sweet and funny storyteller. It’s a light, fun read, and I would certainly recommend it. Her writing style is relatively simple and straightforward, in contrast to how dynamic she is when she’s telling her stories live, but it lacks absolutely none of the charm.
The New York Regional Mormon Singles Halloween Dance: A Memoir, by Elna Baker. $25.95.
Posted by Camilia | No Comments
This book is pretty badass. A good 700 or so pages of enjoyable noir short stories, and an introduction by James Ellroy in which he says things like, “The short stories in this volume are a groove. Exercise your skeevy curiosity and read every one.” Does he only write in noir, or does he speak like that too? Because if I could accurately mimic the tone of first-person voice-overs in noir films, I’d totally go around narrating my life like that.
